Insights

Reading the Paperwork: How Authentication Determines Value

Two identical signatures can be worth wildly different amounts. What separates them is everything that comes with the item.

The first thing I look at on any piece is not the signature. It is the paperwork. In this market, the documentation is half the asset, and sometimes more than half. Two jerseys signed by the same athlete in the same ink can be separated by thousands of dollars purely because of how each one was authenticated.

Witnessed authentication sits at the top

The gold standard is a signing that was witnessed and recorded at the moment it happened. Upper Deck Authenticated pioneered this approach in 1992. Its five step process requires an Upper Deck representative to witness every autograph, keeps a signed record of each session on file, and affixes a serial numbered hologram to each piece, which is matched by a certificate of authenticity and a registration card for the owner.

Programs like this are why UDA pieces from Michael Jordan command a premium. The buyer is not paying for an expert's opinion about a signature. The buyer is paying for a chain of custody that began the moment the pen touched the jersey.

Opinion based authentication

Most autographs on the market were not signed in front of an authenticator. Those pieces are examined after the fact by third party services, which compare the signature against known exemplars and issue a letter of authenticity. A strong letter from a respected authenticator is valuable, but it is an expert opinion rather than a witnessed fact, and the market prices it that way.

Game used is its own discipline

Game used memorabilia adds another layer. A signature proves who held the pen. It says nothing about whether the jersey was ever on the court. For game used pieces, the most valuable evidence is a photo match, where specialists line up unique details such as tagging, stitching, wear and repairs against photographs from a specific game. A jersey matched to a defining night can be worth many multiples of a jersey that is only described as game issued.

The checklist I use

  1. Match every hologram and serial number on the item to the certificate, character by character.
  2. Verify the number with the issuer wherever a database exists, knowing that some older records were never digitized.
  3. Examine the certificate itself. Counterfeiters have copied real certificates and paired them with forged items, so a real number alone is not proof.
  4. Confirm that the item, inscription and edition size match what the paperwork describes.
  5. For game used pieces, require a photo match or documentation from the team or league.
I would rather pass on ten good pieces than own one I cannot prove.

Authentication is not the boring part of this business. It is the business. Every dollar of value in a piece flows from the confidence the next buyer can have in it.

Jonah Sakhai

About the author. Jonah Sakhai is an American entrepreneur and investor from Los Angeles who has been building businesses since childhood. He started Absolute Authentics, a sports memorabilia company, at age 11, and is the co-founder and CEO of Game Worn Swatches, a collectibles company. More about Jonah.

All insights